• Football
  • Baseball
  • Basketball
The 5x5: Sports Loud and Clear.. Read It Now!

Gear Up For Suns Basketball

Is Steve Nash A Hall of Famer?

April 7th, 2009 at 11:02 am

Photobucket

Yesterday, NBA legends Michael Jordan, David Robinson and John Stockton were inducted into the Hall of Fame. This brought up the question to me; with his current career stats, is Steve Nash a Hall of Fame player?

Looking at the 3 major sports in the United States (NBA, NFL and MLB), the Basketball Hall of Fame is definitely the easiest to get into. The main difference with Basketball is the fact there is no specific designation for pro vs. amateur players. Therefore, great college players such Pistol Pete Maravich can get in primarily based on an amateur resume. Granted, Pete Maravich had a solid pro career (24 points and 5.4 assists per game), but without his amazing college statistics at LSU he would likely not be in the Hall of Fame.

Steve Nash is without the benefit of a huge collegiate career. During his 4 years at Santa Clara, he averaged 15 points and a little under 5 assists. In addition, to this point in his NBA career he is without a title which in other sports is almost a pre-requisite unless the person has records at his position I.E. Dan Marino. Steve Nash’s pro career totals are not overwhelming either. Thus far, Nash has averaged 14.4 points, 8 assists, 3 rebounds per game for his career. However, to his credit Nash is a 2-time NBA MVP and his 5 year run in Phoenix has been incredible. Here are his statistics on the Phoenix Suns only: 17.2 points, 10.9 assists and 3 rebounds per game.

To accurately determine if these numbers are Hall of Fame worthy for a Point Guard, one must take a look at Point Guards already in the Hall of Fame.  Here is a list of some prominent Point Guards in the Hall of Fame with Career Points Per Game, Assists and Rebounds in order in parentheses:

Nate Archibald ( 18.8, 7.4, 2.3), Bob Cousy (18.4, 7.5, 5.2), Lenny Wilkens (16.5, 6.7, 4.7), John Stockton (13.1, 10.5, 2.7), Isiah Thomas (19.2, 9.3, 3.6), Walt Frazier (18.9, 6.1, 5.9), Calvin Murphy (17.9, 4.4, 2.1),  Oscar Robertson (25.7, 9.5, 7.5) and Magic Johnson (19.5, 11.2, 7.2).

As you can see from the above list, only 4 of these Hall of Famers had more assists per game than Steve Nash has thus far in his career. However, only one player (John Stockton) scored lower than Steve Nash in terms of his career. The major detriment to Steve Nash is the fact that all of the above players were defensively superior to Nash. However here is why Steve Nash is a Hall of Famer: 9th all-time in assists (total), 12th all-time in assists (average),  5th all-time in career 3-point %, and 2nd all-time free throw %. What clearly distinguishes Nash from all the other Hall of Fame players is that he is bar none the most deadly accurate shooting Point Guard in the history of the NBA.  When Steve Nash retires he will be in the NBA Hall of Hame as soon as he is eligible. Let’s hope he doesn’t retire any time soon and we can keep enjoying watching him play!!

Comments
  • Hey Dennis,

    I agree we are now viewing an era where big men are not dominating as they were in the past. A solid point guard who can penetrate and create is more important that ever. Tony Parker, Chris Paul, Jason Kidd, Deron Williams, Derek Rose, Steve Nash, Chauncey Billups all are potential hall of famers if they stay healthy.
  • Rafal
    I appreciate the numbers analysis but it would also be useful to look at how Nash's numbers compare to the best guards who did not make it into the Hall of Fame -- among those who've been eligible for at least a few years.
  • Thomas
    Of course Nash is going into the Hall (unless there is some bizarre scandal - drugs, gambling, etc.) It's not even debatable. He was a two-time MVP! Case closed.

    As far as Pete Maravich. Of course he would have made the Hall just as a pro. I say this because he was voted a Top 50 NBA player of all time in 1996. That was a more exclusive club than the Hall. And that was based 100% on NBA achievement - no college what-so-ever.

    Now, obviously Pete would have made the Hall even if he never played one minute in the NBA based on his awesome college career.
  • good analysis, hope you deliver this type of fruitful information in future..........
  • dennis mitchell
    Adam,
    Nice analysis of Steve Nash's career totals vs other point guards. In my mind, Nash is a sure hall of fame inductee and I would love to see him elected as soon as possible after retirement. One thing that might hurt him is the sheer number of phenomenal point guards currently in the NBA. The current situation is unprecedented in my memory. We have never had so many superior point guards in the league at one time. If we are talking about Nash going into the Hall then you have to figure that Kidd will also be elected. Then we have Paul, Rose and Williams who also look to have excellent prospects for Hall of Fame careers. Five Hall of Fame type point guards at one time is imcredible. We are lucky to be able to watch all this talent.
  • Josh
    I think he has a place for sure in the Hall Of Fame!!!
  • Joe
    I disagree. You mentioned in your article that a HOF criteria in other sports is to win an championship. With the exception of Wilkens (who was 2nd on the all-time assists list when he retired), all of the PGs you listed here have either won a championship or been to one. Nash has done neither. I think he has put up the numbers to maybe get in to the Hall but I wouldn't say he's a sure-fire first ballot HOF-er.
blog comments powered by Disqus